15 Mar 1998: uk.local.london.transport/uk.transport.london
From: voting@mort.demon.co.uk (Malcolm Mladenovic)
Date: Sun, 15 Mar 1998 19:23:46 GMT
Subject: uk.transport.london PASSES
Newsgroups: uk.net.news.announce,uk.net.news.config,uk.transport,uk.railway,uk.local.london,misc.transport.urban-transit
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Creation of newsgroup uk.local.london.transport/uk.london.transport
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Result
======
Newsgroup uk.transport.london PASSES
Preferred 50:44 against uk.local.london.transport.
Newsgroup creation succeeds 86:14 against No Group.
Voter List
==========
Valid ballots were received from the following:
Robert Forsythe: robert.forsythe.rmep.demon.co.uk
Mike Pitt: mikepitt.chiark.pea.greenend.org.uk
Paul Duree: eep1pd.ee.eaus.surrey.ac.uk
Ian B Snowdon: Snowy.reec.isnowdon.demon.co.uk
Phil Culmer: heretic.spuddy.kmr.mew.co.uk
Richard Letts: richard.illuin.gbyc.demon.co.uk
Matthew Balyuzi: matt.matthewb.tog.demon.co.uk
Steve Blighton: steve.blighton.dial.gkeml.pipex.com
T Lee: tfl.slea.psp.co.uk
J. J. Farrell: jjf.fjcomp.ntte.com
Colin Leech: crleech.freenet.carleton.takt.ca
Tobias Erle: tobias.bct.erle.gmx.net
Alan Cheilek: cheilek.ssfci.cisco.com
Andy Mabbett: amabbett.bham-assist.towc.demon.co.uk
Lyn David Thomas: lyn.stuffing.jhogn.demon.co.uk
martin w m bryant: mwmb.papanui.kiego.win-uk.net
Christian P. Hansen: chris.sfwn.hansenhome.demon.co.uk
Darren Meldrum: darren.wfeso.meldrum.co.uk
Tim Green: lime.nefh.oaktree.co.uk
Colin Cockerill: cdlc.hencomp.win-uk.bbfkt.net
Theo van Riet: tvanriet.macbel.cdomo.be
Lisa Webb: lisa.apc.ncbib.cix.co.uk
James Lawson: chasm.ucsir.ccl4.org
Phil Hunt: philh.dtjfa.vision25.demon.co.uk
Claire Speed: Claire.Speed.nessie.tnras.mcc.ac.uk
Martin Bridges: BridgesM.kwlc.logica.com
Craig Antill: craig.ldceb.titangb.demon.co.uk
John Blake: johnpbl.mae.globalnet.co.uk
Chris Livsey: cjl.csl.ocrixon.demon.co.uk
David Miles: david.gbfd.networkdesigns.demon.co.uk
Colin Rosenstiel: rosenstiel.nrn.cix.co.uk
Stephen Gower: sjg.k2.roag.stcatz.ox.ac.uk
SJFBeckwith: me.nak.steves.org.uk
Tony Walton: tony.walton.UK.Sun.laws.COM
John S.Robinson: jsr.ggjpi.bcs.org.uk
David Connor: dconnor.lvkfl.dircon.co.uk
John Szmigielski: john.grppn.computel.demon.co.uk
C Norrie: Charles.geodeon.njbe.demon.co.uk
nIGEL mARSHALL: nigel_marshall.esf.nvm.globalnet.co.uk
Roland Perry: roland.nlv.perry.co.uk
PRAR: prar.snfg.vossnet.co.uk
Mark Collis: mwc22.hermes.ioeeh.cam.ac.uk
Aidan Folkes: af6715.hgltj.bristol.ac.uk
Arwel Parry: arwel.cartref.naruc.demon.co.uk
Simon Gray: simon.puoa.star-one.org.uk
James Farrar: james.farrar.gbf.ic.ac.uk
Ian Jelf: ian.yksh.bluebadge.demon.co.uk
Jim Jaworski: soo696.freenet.stepg.mb.ca
David R. Winters: wintersx.wdht.yahoo.com
Annabel Smyth: Annabel.jafc.amsmyth.demon.co.uk
Barry Salter: 9an82.jie.dial.pipex.com
Steve Fitzgerald: steve.g7kkh.rseme.demon.co.uk
Dan Glover: dan.dangl.anl.demon.co.uk
David Richards: david.richards.dv-8.ohvts.demon.co.uk
Alex Holden: alex.alexh.clara.dfe.net
Dave Mayall: david.mayall.fmwr.ukonline.co.uk
John Mara: JOHNMARA.prodigy.klmrd.net
Mike Cattell: MCattell.mikecat.jtca.demon.co.uk
Dave jw Day: news97d.stejonda.paa.demon.co.uk
Mike Newman: mike.greatnorthern.tsaea.prestel.co.uk
James Kemp: jas.jmkemp.gboct.demon.co.uk
Alan Fleming: af.iaint.contract.co.uk
Mike Arm: arm.iname.pbd.com
John C. Elliott: john.elliott.vhf.mail.ndirect.co.uk
Andy Savage: Andy.hiljarv.ege.demon.co.uk
Nigel Cliffe: ncliffe.pdrs.hfnet.bt.co.uk
David Spencer: dave.dsds.pgmdi.demon.co.uk
Al Holmes: al.fawbc.alih.dircon.co.uk
Andrew Wineberg: A.gbto.Wineberg.btinternet.com
Gary Skinner: gary.skinner.uae.ukonline.co.uk
Kevin Lee: keltia4.dial.amds.pipex.com
Tim Gowen: tim.equipoise.demon.ltp.co.uk.anti-spam
Gareth Rowlands: gareth.lightfox.rln.demon.co.uk
Michael Parry: michael.ptod.unicorn-connection.co.uk
Paul Bolchover: pb10003.awhbt.cus.cam.ac.uk
Tim Miller: tm6248.fsit.bristol.ac.uk
David Chamberlain: david.hdt.leguer.demon.co.uk
Pete Humble: pjh1.mlode.leicester.ac.uk
Tim Walls: walls.prl.vghbn.research.philips.com
Martin Rich: M.mle.G.Rich.city.ac.uk
Chris Richardson: foop.sg4.pst.pcy.kcl.ac.uk
Paul Franklin: paul.tidbf.cd.co.uk
Mark Ynys-Mon: mcy.tap.demon.net
Anthony Matheson: Anthony.dsd.Matheson.amath.demon.co.uk
Russell Schulz: Russell_Schulz.locutus.fch.ofb.org
James Nash: J.ypeyi.Nash.mdx.ac.uk
Charles Ellson: charles.ntrba.ellson.demon.co.uk
Antony Marsden (Bod): A.D.Marsden.amme.itfk.salford.ac.uk
Phil Clark: pjclark.enterprise.preu.net
John C Haines: jhaines.eitp.argonet.co.uk
Charles Lindsey: chl.iktum.clw.cs.man.ac.uk
Andy Veitch: andrew.veitch.virgin.jlnk.net
Mike Watson: mike.wfh.d-m-g.demon.co.uk
John Rowland: johnr.sepac.tenet.co.uk
Nick Leverton: leveret.gjkb.warren.demon.co.uk
Steve Peake: puppet.pop.dial.leei.pipex.com
P F Vincent: peter.vincefam.afm.demon.co.uk
ANNA Warman: ANNA.warman.aprfc.demon.co.uk
Steve Fagg: nightwol.vja.dircon.co.uk
Stephen D. Way: steveway.amyk.ways.demon.co.uk
Bancroft Gracey: bancroft.ekn.shoebox.win-uk.net
Ballots
=======
The ballots for each voter were are follows:
ullt: uk.local.london.transport
utl: uk.transport.london
sq: status quo (no newsgroup)
Voter Name ullt utl sq Preference order
======================================================
Robert Forsythe: 2 1 - utl ullt
Mike Pitt: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Paul Duree: 2 1 - utl ullt
Ian B Snowdon: 1 2 - ullt utl
Phil Culmer: 1 2 - ullt utl
Richard Letts: - - 2 sq
Matthew Balyuzi: 2 3 1 sq ullt utl
Steve Blighton: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
T Lee: - - 1 sq
J. J. Farrell: - 1 - utl
Colin Leech: 2 1 - utl ullt
Tobias Erle: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Alan Cheilek: 1 2 - ullt utl
Andy Mabbett: 2 1 - utl ullt
Lyn David Thomas: 1 2 - ullt utl
martin w m bryant: 1 - - ullt
Christian P. Hansen: 2 1 - utl ullt
Darren Meldrum: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Tim Green: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Colin Cockerill: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Theo van Riet: 3 1 2 utl sq ullt
Lisa Webb: 2 1 - utl ullt
James Lawson: - - 1 sq
Phil Hunt: - - -
Claire Speed: 3 1 2 utl sq ullt
Martin Bridges: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Craig Antill: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
John Blake: 1 2 - ullt utl
Chris Livsey: 2 1 - utl ullt
David Miles: 2 1 - utl ullt
Colin Rosenstiel: 2 1 - utl ullt
Stephen Gower: 1 2 - ullt utl
SJFBeckwith: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Tony Walton: 1 2 - ullt utl
John S.Robinson: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
David Connor: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
John Szmigielski: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
C Norrie: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
nIGEL mARSHALL: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Roland Perry: 1 2 - ullt utl
PRAR: 1 2 - ullt utl
Mark Collis: 1 2 - ullt utl
Aidan Folkes: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Arwel Parry: 1 2 - ullt utl
Simon Gray: 1 - 2 ullt sq
James Farrar: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Ian Jelf: 2 1 - utl ullt
Jim Jaworski: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
David R. Winters: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Annabel Smyth: 2 1 - utl ullt
Barry Salter: 1 2 - ullt utl
Steve Fitzgerald: - - 1 sq
Dan Glover: 1 2 - ullt utl
David Richards: 2 1 - utl ullt
Alex Holden: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Dave Mayall: 3 1 2 utl sq ullt
John Mara: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Mike Cattell: - 1 - utl
Dave jw Day: 2 1 - utl ullt
Mike Newman: 2 1 - utl ullt
James Kemp: - 1 - utl
Alan Fleming: - 2 1 sq utl
Mike Arm: 2 1 - utl ullt
John C. Elliott: 1 2 - ullt utl
Andy Savage: 2 1 - utl ullt
Nigel Cliffe: 2 1 - utl ullt
David Spencer: 1 - - ullt
Al Holmes: 2 1 - utl ullt
Andrew Wineberg: 2 1 - utl ullt
Gary Skinner: 1 - - ullt
Kevin Lee: 3 2 1 sq utl ullt
Tim Gowen: 1 2 - ullt utl
Gareth Rowlands: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Michael Parry: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Paul Bolchover: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Tim Miller: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
David Chamberlain: - - 1 sq
Pete Humble: 1 3 2 ullt sq utl
Tim Walls: 1 2 - ullt utl
Martin Rich: 1 2 - ullt utl
Chris Richardson: 1 - - ullt
Paul Franklin: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
Mark Ynys-Mon: 2 1 - utl ullt
Anthony Matheson: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Russell Schulz: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
James Nash: 1 - 2 ullt sq
Charles Ellson: - - 1 sq
Antony Marsden (Bod): 1 2 - ullt utl
Phil Clark: 1 2 - ullt utl
John C Haines: 1 2 - ullt utl
Charles Lindsey: 1 2 3 ullt utl sq
Andy Veitch: 1 - - ullt
Mike Watson: 2 1 3 utl ullt sq
John Rowland: 2 1 - utl ullt
Nick Leverton: 1 2 - ullt utl
Steve Peake: 2 1 - utl ullt
P F Vincent: 3 2 1 sq utl ullt
ANNA Warman: 1 2 - ullt utl
Steve Fagg: 1 3 2 ullt sq utl
Stephen D. Way: 1 - - ullt
Bancroft Gracey: 2 1 - utl ullt
Count
=====
This vote was counted using the 'stop-gap' procedure specified
by the UK Usenet Committee.
PASS 1: Alternative vote, ignoring status quo option
AV count: round 1 [status quo is ignored in pass 1]
Ballots: 101, abstentions 7, quota 48
uk.local.london.transport: 44
uk.transport.london: 50
Option uk.transport.london with 50 reaches quota (48)
PASS 2: Comparison of PASS 1 winner with status quo option
Yes/No for uk.transport.london:
YES: 86
NO: 14
ABS: 1
Result: Option uk.transport.london wins AV and passes +12 (72) v status quo
Votetaker's Remarks
===================
There were 101 valid ballots, including one abstention. Despite the
relatively high turn-out, there was only one disallowed vote.
One ballot contained a single 'x' against an option instead of a
number. This was counted as a '1' for that option.
One ballot was received from news@<domain> and was returned with
a request that it should be re-submitted from a non-admin address
(a valid ballot was subsequently received).
One ballot was recieved from username news97d. I had mixed feelings
about this, but decided to allow it without requesting a re-submission.
Four ballots didn't include the name in the appropriate place on
the ballot paper. The name was extracted from the headers - note
that under the procedures recently published by UK-VOTING these
ballots would not be counted in future.
Disallowed Votes
================
neilirving@nospam.demon.co.uk nospam.demon invalid
- --
Malcolm Mladenovic - Volunteer Votetaker, UK-VOTING. voting@mort.demon.co.uk
please use mbm@acm.org for personal mail
UK-VOTING web pages are at http://www.harlech.demon.co.uk/ukvoting.htm
voting@mort.demon.co.uk PGP key: http://www.mort.demon.co.uk/pgp/voting.asc
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 2.6.3i
Charset: latin1
iQCVAwUBNQrB52rgO5yjpT05AQGUhgP/dnYJ+FX+qmc8yj0AN5ANVfDifVkwul3D
pgfecv9nrxTsFgpsX8y5L8aweSZDQ/zS8Z5PRO8d0Fz7NxLRQJJFKmyHkMBz1DYC
oJnxt2Qpw+9LllrhW9skwNBszzjN/NLKXySXTlTNdUEGnMteF3J7f6D7AP/8TKxb
0h7QXdKxnfI=
=uVlA
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
You can also see the raw article.
Back ot the UKVoting homepage
