30 Dec 1997: A Motion of No Confidence in the UK Usenet Committee

From: Steven Inglis <Voting@bcde.demon.co.uk>
Date: Tue, 30 Dec 1997 22:18:07 GMT
Subject: Revised: Result: Vote of No Confidence
Newsgroups: uk.net.news.config,uk.net.news.announce,uk.net,uk.politics.misc


     Revised Result: Motion of No Confidence in the UK Usenet Committee  
     Voting closed 23:59:59 GMT, 24th November 1997.  

This vote was conducted by a neutral third party member of UK-VOTING.
UK-VOTING is a group of independent votetakers who count votes on
CFV's in the uk hierarchy. The rules under which this vote was taken
are posted regularly to uk.net.news.announce or can be found at the
following URL:

For voting questions only contact ukvoting@bcde.demon.co.uk
(Steven Inglis).

SUMMARY: Motion of No Confidence FAILS 48:209

There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.
Allegations of irregularity should be sent to control@usenet.org.uk.

	Distribution:    uk.net.news.announce
 	Neil Fernandez <ncf{at}borve[dot].{demon.[dot]co.uk}>

For several weeks now the UK Usenet Committee has been under flak, and
this Motion of No Confidence is the result of the criticisms which
have been made.

In a nutshell, the Committee stands accused of treating the uk.*
hierarchy (i.e. the part of 'network news' containing newsgroups
beginning with uk.) AS ITS PRIVATE PROPERTY. This is considered to be
thoroughly improper in a body most of whose members are elected by the
community at large. The Committee should be accountable. And by means
of this vote it is being made accountable.

One of the aims, if and when the community expresses its lack of
confidence in the Committee, is to start the ball rolling to make the
next Committee more accountable in future. No longer must members of
the community be discouraged from taking part in important discussions
(e.g. on the creation of new newsgroups) by arrogance and manipulation
on the part of the members of the Committee. It is unfortunate,
though, that at the moment there is quite a lot of scope for Committee
members to act in this way, and they are taking full advantage of that
scope. If things are going to change, voting against them in a vote of
no confidence is seen as unavoidable. This opportunity may well not
arise again for some time.

Specific criticisms made include the following:

- - the case of the self-help education group. What happened here
was that a vote was held and the results were counted. The Committee
received those results. The proposal was adjudged by the vote-taker to
have passed. The group should have been created. But having received
the results, the Committee then made changes to counting procedures
and declared the proposal a failure. 

   It is held that this involved an utter scorn for existing
precedent; a compromising of the position of the independent
vote-taking organisation UK-VOTING; and a contempt for their own

- - the policy of secrecy. According to the current members'
understanding of the system of 'collective responsibility', the
community is not informed of who voted which way in committee votes,
nor even of each member's level of contribution to committee
discussions. This is more akin to a system of 'omerta'. It is
respected by every single Committee member - a policy of silence.

- -  Related to this, the current committee's mode of operation is
frequently appalling. This can involve the posting of articles and the
sending of e-mails which correspondents may be allowed to believe have
been sent with the 'authority of the committee'. E.g. committee
members give the impression 'as individuals' that such-and-such is the
'rule' or the 'accepted procedure', and that therefore the proponent
must make such-and-such an amendment to his proposal (e.g. that as
long as a naming option has received 'sufficient' support on
uk.net.news.config, a proponent MUST include it on the ballot-form,
however offensive it might be to the group's proposed readership. In
actual fact it is up to the proponent to prepare the ballot-form in
co-operation with the vote-taker!) People are basically BULLIED into
thinking the rules state XYZ when they do not. At a later date this
can all be described as 'just a private opinion' - after all, most
proponents don't hang around on uk.net.news.config for very long.

In short, they make 'precedent' up as they go along, and they
frequently TRAMPLE ALL OVER IT. Sometimes they try to do it on the
quiet; at other times they are quite brazen. One Committee member, for
example, has repeatedly asserted that 'there is no precedent'. This is
very illuminatory of the ARBITRARY fashion in which the Committee
operates. Many votes were held under certain vote-counting rules, for
example, but that did not stop the Committee from changing those rules
when it wished to. Similarly, votes have been held which would have
involved the creation of a new 'hierarchy' for which a charter had not
yet been proposed. I.e. people have voted on the creation of a group
called uk.A.B, where no previous group had a name beginning uk.A
This has happened without a toot of objection from the
Committee. But this didn't stop Control, acting on behalf of the
Committee, from turning down a recent Request for Discussion of a
proposal of this type on precisely these grounds. Without an official
posting of such a Request, the group cannot be created. Committee
members have backed this up by saying that they didn't like that
specific option on the draft. What arrogance! What contempt!

It is undoubtedly the case that some members act in a far more
disgraceful way than others towards the community at large. Some seem
to take more pleasure than others in being obstructive, arbitrary,
manipulative, and bullying. But at the same time there really is
collective responsibility because so far NO-ONE has resigned in

It was perhaps inevitable that the Committee would be like this, and
that the atmosphere on uk.net.news.config would be redolent of a
'private club'. Clearly introducing elections for Committee posts was
not enough to change this. Real change can only come from below. But
that is precisely the main part of the 'Rationale' behind the MOTION

Voters are urged to decide for themselves whether they think the
existing modus operandi is wrong, and if they do, how wrong they think
it is. This motion of no confidence is proposed on the basis of the
idea that what we need most of all is for the current elected members

- --------------------------------------------------------------------------


The following list of addresses is copyright 1996 Steven Inglis. Use
for any purpose other than verifying the vote for this newsgroup is

There were 209 votes of confidence, 48 votes of no confidence and
22 Abstains for a total of 279 valid votes.

Motion of No Confidence Final Vote Ack
No Confidence Vote Final Vote Ack

Voted Yes - For Confidence in the Uk Usenet Committee

No Confidence Vote Final Vote Ack

Voted Yes - For confidence in the Uk Usenet Committee
- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
af6715[.at}.bristol.ca.ku                               Aidan Alexander Folkes
af[.at}.contract.oc.ku                                            Alan Fleming
afrost[.at}.acorn.cmo                                            Anthony Frost
afy9faj[.at}.unix.ccc.nottingham.ca.ku                              A J FOSTER
alan[.at}.chorazin.ogr.ku                                          Alan Glover
amabbett[.at}.bham-assist.demon.oc.ku                        Birmingham ASSIST
amethyst[.at}.jadzia.demon.oc.ku                                      Amethyst
andrewm[.at}.chiark.greenend.ogr.ku                               Andrew Mobbs
andy[.at}.oznet.demon.oc.ku                                       Andy Osborne
anima[.at}.devi.demon.oc.ku                                     Devi Jankowicz
Annabel[.at}.amsmyth.demon.oc.ku                                 Annabel Smyth
anne.mchenry[.at}.zetnet.oc.ku                                    Anne McHenry 
Anne[.at}.ramkaran.demon.oc.ku                                   Anne Ramkaran
arwel[.at}.cartref.demon.oc.ku                                     Arwel Parry
aw1[.at}.stade.oc.ku                                           Adrian Wontroba
bajones[.at}.larkhill.win-uk.nte                                   Brian Jones
barry.salter[.at}.pemail.nte                                      Barry Salter
bazzas[.at}.btinternet.cmo                                         Barry Smith
bellaire[.at}.iquest.nte                                        James Bellaire
bj[.at}.camino.demon.oc.ku                                       Barry Johnson
bjh21[.at}.cam.ca.ku                                                Ben Harris
bly[.at}.star.rl.ca.ku                                              Martin Bly
Bob[.at}.delands.demon.oc.ku                                        Bob Moakes
bounce[.at}.genest.demon.oc.ku                              Charlie Freckleton
Brennig_Jones[.at}.bathnes.gov.ku                                Brennig Jones
BridgesM[.at}.logica.cmo                                        Bridges Martin
briggs[.at}.radstone.oc.ku                                        David Briggs
broonie[.at}.tardis.ed.ca.ku                                        Mark Brown
catcher[.at}.ntecomuk.oc.ku                                    Chris Hutchings
ccx061[.at}.coventry.ca.ku                                   Wendy A.S. Taylor
ch[.at}.chch.demon.oc.ku                                        Charles Bryant
chasm[.at}.ccl4.ogr                                               jAmES Lawson
chris[.at}.cimio.oc.ku                                            Chris Turner
chris[.at}.dickson.demon.oc.ku                                   Chris Dickson
chris[.at}.isbell.demon.oc.ku                                     Chris Isbell
chris[.at}.mnemosyne.demon.oc.ku                          Christopher Dearlove
christopher[.at}.uffa.demon.oc.ku                          Christopher Watkins
colin[.at}.msc.thchem.ox.ca.ku                                 Colin Batchelor
crn[.at}.netix.demon.oc.ku                                          C. Newport
daleym[.at}.ku.psi.cmo                                            Marcus Daley
damerell[.at}.chiark.greenend.ogr.ku                            David Damerell
dan[.at}.dangl.demon.oc.ku                                          Dan Glover
darren[.at}.meldrum.oc.ku                                       Darren Meldrum
Dave.Sparks[.at}.sisyphus.demon.oc.ku                              Dave Sparks
dave[.at}.b-field.demon.oc.ku                                 David Bloomfield
dave[.at}.darob.demon.oc.ku                                       Dave Roberts
dave[.at}.demon.nte                                              Dave Williams
dave[.at}.dsds.demon.oc.ku                                       David Spencer
dave[.at}.stejonda.demon.oc.ku                                        Dave Day
daveh[.at}.teleord.oc.ku                                             Dave Helm
david[.at}.bloor.demon.oc.ku                                    David M. Bloor
david[.at}.election.demon.oc.ku                                David Boothroyd
david[.at}.tcs01.demon.oc.ku                                       David James
david[.at}.wood2.demon.oc.ku                                        David Wood
davtom[.at}.drmach.demon.oc.ku                                 David J. Thomas
dferguson[.at}.sol.oc.ku                                         Dave Ferguson
dolores[.at}.birdroom.clara.oc.ku                               Dolores Noonan
Don[.at}.whybrow.demon.oc.ku                                       Don Whybrow
dweller[.at}.ramtops.demon.oc.ku                                   Doug Weller
eaking[.at}.ulape.demon.oc.ku                                      Edward King
ecurrie[.at}.netcomuk.oc.ku                                   Edward H. Currie
esrqo[.at}.csv.warwick.ca.ku                                      GAVIN PORTER
fredb[.at}.frolix8.demon.oc.ku                                     Fred Barber
george[.at}.zingaro.demon.oc.ku                                 George Flinter
Gerard[.at}.galatham.demon.oc.ku                            Gerard Alan Latham
Graham[.at}.grempc.demon.oc.ku                                  Graham E Kinns
grovesa[.at}.cco.caltech.edu                                       Andy Groves
huge[.at}.axalotl.demon.oc.ku                                      Hugh Davies
hugh[.at}.st-ronan.demon.oc.ku                                    Hugh Simmons
I.G.Batten[.at}.ftel.oc.ku                                        Ian G Batten
iain[.at}.hotch.demon.oc.ku                                     Iain Hotchkies
iainr[.at}.civ.hw.ca.ku                                               Iain RAe
ian[.at}.johnrich.demon.oc.ku                                      Ian Peattie
ian[.at}.melvin.dp.ox.ca.ku                                        I J Clifton
idaniel[.at}.jesus.ox.ca.ku                                      Illtud Daniel
ijackson[.at}.chiark.greenend.ogr.ku                               Ian Jackson
irowan[.at}.netcomuk.oc.ku                                          Iain Rowan
J.F.Wheeler[.at}.rl.ca.ku                                     Jonathan Wheeler
J.W.Harley[.at}.warwick.ca.ku                                       Jon Harley
J.Yeates[.at}.sussex.ca.ku                                         John Yeates
jad[.at}.ku.psi.cmo                                                 James Dyer
jah[.at}.ilena.demon.oc.ku                                         Jeremy Hall
jajones[.at}.ermine.ox.ca.ku                                    Jonathan Jones
james[.at}.biometry.demon.oc.ku                                     James Lynn
James[.at}.jmkemp.demon.oc.ku                                       James Kemp
janet.mcknight[.at}.pembroke.oxford.ca.ku                       Janet McKnight
jdan[.at}.mail.nerc-bidston.ca.ku                                  James Annan
jesus[.at}.news.heaven.oc.ku                                      Jason Crouch
Jim[.at}.jh-c.demon.oc.ku                                             Jim Hill
Jim[.at}.maddison.demon.oc.ku                                     Jim Maddison
jjf[.at}.fjcomp.cmo                                              J. J. Farrell
john[.at}.jhall.demon.oc.ku                                          John Hall
john[.at}.thebeard.demon.oc.ku                                   John Robinson
john[.at}.thegreys.demon.oc.ku                                       John Grey
jon[.at}.oaktree.oc.ku                                             Jon Ribbens
jrk[.at}.sys.uea.ca.ku                                        Richard Kennaway
jrr[.at}.atml.oc.ku                                               John Rickard
jrs[.at}.merlyn.demon.oc.ku                                   Dr John Stockton
jsr[.at}.bcs.ogr.ku                                            John S.Robinson
jsw[.at}.isise.rl.ca.ku                                            John Wright
kcrolph[.at}.kgames.demon.oc.ku                                    Kevin Rolph
kirsty[.at}.loquax.demon.oc.ku                               Kirsty Darbyshire
kris[.at}.aimless.demon.oc.ku                                       Chris Keen
larry[.at}.crl130.demon.oc.ku                                    Larry Treanor
Lesley[.at}.corwyn.demon.oc.ku                                  Lesley Simpson
leveret[.at}.warren.demon.oc.ku                                  Nick Leverton
lnr[.at}.lspace.ogr                                              Eleanor Blair
lyn[.at}.stuffing.demon.oc.ku                                 Lyn David Thomas
M.Biddiscombe[.at}.ucl.ca.ku                                Martin Biddiscombe
Marcus[.at}.zenn.demon.oc.ku                                     Marcus Durham
Mark.Dickman[.at}.elmail.oc.ku                                    Mark Dickman
Mark.Gould[.at}.bristol.ca.ku                                       Mark Gould
mark[.at}.devon.demon.oc.ku                                         Mark Cross
Mark[.at}.ellmar.demon.oc.ku                                        Mark Eller
mark[.at}.good-stuff.oc.ku                                         Mark Goodge
markh[.at}.msicam.oc.ku                                          Mark Harrison
markt[.at}.ku.uu.nte                                               Mark Turner
martin[.at}.zamenhof.demon.oc.ku                                Martin Radford
maxine[.at}.iii.oc.ku                                           Maxine Lehmann
mayalld[.at}.it.postoffice.oc.ku                                   Dave Mayall
mbaker[.at}.iee.ogr                                                 Mark Baker
mbm[.at}.cam.ogr                                            Malcolm Mladenovic
mbran[.at}.csv.warwick.ca.ku                                      Keith Church
me[.at}.steves.ogr.ku                                      Stephen JF Beckwith
mel[.at}.vanyel.herald.oc.ku                             Melanie Dymond Harper
michael[.at}.unicorn-connection.oc.ku                            Michael Parry
mikepitt[.at}.chiark.greenend.ogr.ku                                 Mike Pitt
mk270[.at}.hermes.cam.ca.ku                                      Martin Keegan
mph[.at}.atc.dera.gov.ku                                      Michael Humphrey
mpr22[.at}.hermes.cam.ca.ku                                        Martin Read
mwd2[.at}.leica.oc.ku                                         Mike Wilmot-Dear
ncliffe[.at}.hfnet.bt.oc.ku                                       Nigel Cliffe
ngd[.at}.aber.ca.ku                                             Neil Gary Dodd
nick[.at}.derby.ogr                                               Nick Sellors
nigel.scott[.at}.dial.pipex.cmo                                          scott
Nigel.Titley[.at}.bt.nte                                          Nigel Titley
nigel[.at}.ashton.demon.oc.ku                                     Nigel Ashton
nja[.at}.leicester.ca.ku                                         Andrew Norman
nuala[.at}.happyfun.ogr                                            Nuala Fahey
p-dent[.at}.ti.cmo                                                  Peter Dent
paul.martin[.at}.nuffield.oxford.ca.ku                             Paul Martin
paul[.at}.awe.cmo                                                  Paul Sutton
pb10003[.at}.cus.cam.ca.ku                                      Paul Bolchover
pepworth[.at}.netcomuk.oc.ku                                     Gary Pepworth
pete[.at}.ento.demon.oc.ku                                        Peter Murphy
pete[.at}.physchem.ox.ca.ku                                         Pete Biggs
Peter[.at}.wppltd.demon.oc.ku                                      Peter Parry
Pfeif324[.at}.concentric.nte                               Dale Allen Pfeiffer
pgpga[.at}.csv.warwick.ca.ku                                        R.G.Taylor
ph[.at}.anweald.exnet.oc.ku                                    Patrick Herring
pherber[.at}.pherber.cmo                                           Paul Herber
phil[.at}.webcor.demon.oc.ku                                       Phil Martin
pja1002[.at}.cus.cam.ca.ku                                    Philip Armstrong
pjclark[.at}.enterprise.nte                                         Phil Clark
pjh1[.at}.leicester.ca.ku                                          Pete Humble
pla[.at}.sktb.demon.oc.ku                                        Paul L. Allen
pm215[.at}.cam.ca.ku                                             Peter Maydell
ppp[.at}.pirinen.demon.oc.ku                                  Pekka P. Pirinen
R.Flood[.at}.noc.ulcc.ca.ku                                        Ronan Flood
richard.herring[.at}.gecm.cmo                                  Richard Herring
Richard.Watts[.at}.cl.cam.ca.ku                                  Richard Watts
Richard[.at}.challrj.demon.oc.ku                               Richard Challis
richard[.at}.corixia.demon.oc.ku                                Richard Ashton
richard[.at}.greenend.ogr.ku                                           Richard
richard[.at}.stonix.demon.oc.ku                                 Richard Lamont
richard[.at}.tga.u-net.cmo                                     Richard Gadsden
richard[.at}.turnpike.cmo                                      Richard Clayton
rick.martin[.at}.pixel-group.cmo                                   Rick Martin
rjd4[.at}.cam.ca.ku                                                Bob Dowling
rob[.at}.akra.demon.oc.ku                                            Rob Allen
robbie[.at}.arakeen.demon.oc.ku                                  robbie irvine
rod[.at}.null.nte                                                   Rod Begbie
rosenstiel[.at}.cix.oc.ku                                     Colin Rosenstiel
sales[.at}.tsaco.demon.oc.ku                                          H. Smith
saltash[.at}.btinternet.cmo                                          ian jason
simon[.at}.jasmine.ogr.ku                                         Simon Brooke
siona[.at}.chiark.greenend.ogr.ku                              Sion Arrowsmith
sjg[.at}.k2.stcatz.ox.ca.ku                                      stephen gower
slewin[.at}.zetnet.oc.ku                                           Steve Lewin
slt[.at}.psp.oc.ku                                            Susan Lee-Tanner
spamtrap[.at}.kalevala.demon.oc.ku                                Roy Stilling
steve[.at}.fell.demon.oc.ku                                       Steve Glover
steve[.at}.tigertech.demon.oc.ku                               Steve Hutchings 
stevem[.at}.chiark.greenend.ogr.ku                              Steve McIntyre
steven.clarke[.at}.monmouth.demon.oc.ku                          Steven Clarke
steven.m9[.at}.kuonline.oc.ku                                    Steven Mayall
steveway[.at}.ways.demon.oc.ku                                       Steve Way
Steve_Kilbane[.at}.cegelecproj.oc.ku                             Steve Kilbane
stuart[.at}.boxatrix.demon.oc.ku                                Stuart Baldwin
stuart[.at}.dcre.leeds.ca.ku                                    S. Butterfield
susan[.at}.ashton.demon.oc.ku                                     Susan Ashton
sweh[.at}.mpn.cmo                                               Stephen Harris
swfb[.at}.bokop.win-uk.nte                                    S.W.F. Borthwick
sxw[.at}.dcs.ed.ca.ku                                          Simon Wilkinson
T.Clark[.at}.warwick.ca.ku                                           Tim Clark
T.M.Forcer[.at}.ecs.soton.ca.ku                                     Tim Forcer
telecom[.at}.dircon.oc.ku                                        Steve Ellwood
tgold[.at}.panix.cmo                                           Anthony R. Gold
thomas.womack[.at}.merton.oxford.ca.ku                           Thomas Womack
tim[.at}.mcc.ca.ku                                            Tim Shuttleworth
Timothy.Ricketts[.at}.ox.ca.ku                                    Tim Ricketts
tjsharrock[.at}.iee.ogr                                           Tim Sharrock
tom[.at}.cmopton.demon.oc.ku                                        Tom Hughes
tomcat[.at}.verrine.demon.oc.ku                                  Peter Corlett
uhaa032[.at}.sun.rhbnc.ca.ku                                       Malcolm Ray
upson[.at}.cableol.oc.ku                                            Nick Upson
vashti[.at}.drmach.demon.oc.ku                                   Rachael Munns
wibble[.at}.fishblanket.demon.oc.ku                                Tony Towers
ZLSIIDA[.at}.fs1.mcc.ca.ku                                           Dave Budd

Voted No - For No Confidence in the Uk Usenet Committee
- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
adm[.at}.minuet.demon.oc.ku                                  Valerie Langfield
alan[.at}.the-one.demon.oc.ku                                             Alan
andrew[.at}.hougie.oc.ku                                         Andrew Hougie
andrewc[.at}.nildram.nte                                       Andrew Crawford
ANDY_W2[.at}.sfov1.verifone.cmo                                    ANDY WALKER
angus[.at}.gulliver1.demon.oc.ku                                Angus Gulliver
awhiteb[.at}.cix.cmopulink.oc.ku                                    Alan White
camaleon[.at}.one.nte.au                                        Marcel Bennett
chrisc[.at}.pobox.oc.ku                                           Chris Clough
Damon[.at}.daro.demon.oc.ku                                              Damon
david.hastings[.at}.computing-services.oxford.ca.ku             David Hastings
djones[.at}.borve.demon.oc.ku                                      David Jones
dmahon[.at}.amigo.demon.oc.ku                                      David Mahon
dmjones[.at}.chomsky.arts.adelaide.edu.au                         Darren Jones
edmund[.at}.xibalba.demon.oc.ku                                  Edmund Searle
foz[.at}.xs4all.nl                                                Suzan Foster
fsgpr[.at}.aurora.alaska.edu                                      Gregory Roby
gp[.at}.mamba.demon.oc.ku                                         Gavin Lawson
jamccoy[.at}.maurabrid.win-uk.nte                                   John McCoy
jason[.at}.ullscarf.demon.oc.ku                                  Jason Waghorn
jonivar[.at}.ph.ed.ca.ku                                    jon ivar skullerud
jpff[.at}.maths.bath.ca.ku                                          John Fitch
keith[.at}.cowtown.demon.oc.ku                                Keith Willoughby
krl[.at}.keltia4.prestel.oc.ku                                       Kevin Lee
kwgxxh[.at}.echidna.stu.cowan.edu.au                              Mark LOCKETT
martin.howard[.at}.qnet.ogr.ku                                   Martin Howard
Matthew_Robb[.at}.MCKINSEY.cmo                                    Matthew Robb
miballar[.at}.leland.Stanford.EDU                           Michael T. Ballard
mikel[.at}.datasync.cmo                                       Michael Giardino
miketan[.at}.duntone.demon.oc.ku                                      Mike Tan
ncf[.at}.borve.demon.oc.ku                                      Neil Fernandez
nick[.at}.knot.demon.oc.ku                                                Nick
npch[.at}.tardis.ed.ca.ku                                       Neil Chue Hong
octobersdad[.at}.reporters.nte                                     Bruce Tober
olgoat[.at}.kdsi.nte                                                 Bob Gambs
philh[.at}.vision25.demon.oc.ku                                    Philip Hunt
puppet[.at}.pop.dial.pipex.cmo                                     Steve Peake
pydan[.at}.swansea.ca.ku                                      Donal O'Driscoll
R.E.Horne[.at}.shu.ca.ku                                           Ralph Horne
rob[.at}.bluenoze.demon.oc.ku                                         Rob Hill
russ[.at}.antigrav.demon.oc.ku                                   Colin F. Russ
sam[.at}.mimosa.demon.oc.ku                                           Sam Bond
sarah[.at}.sattva.demon.oc.ku                                    SARAH CLAYTON
Schmidg[.at}.netcom.ca                                       Albert G. Schmidt
sinkers[.at}.myhouse.cmo                                    Michael Swartzbeck
steve[.at}.guitars.powernet.oc.ku                                 Steve Cobham
tenaeile[.at}.ix.netcom.cmo                                               tena
toastman[.at}.rahul.nte                                            David Young

- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
abelard[.at}.abelard.demon.oc.ku                                       abelard
adickson[.at}.stirmargrev.demon.oc.ku                         Alastair Dickson
ajtr2[.at}.cam.ca.ku                                                  Alex Ray
alaric[.at}.harlech.demon.oc.ku                                     Iain Bowen
chl[.at}.clw.cs.man.ca.ku                                      Charles Lindsey
chris[.at}.vineries.demon.oc.ku                                    Chris Watts
Claire.Speed[.at}.mailhost.mcc.ca.ku                              Claire Speed
gfrancis[.at}.doradus.u-net.cmo                                 Gareth Francis
hopper[.at}.ooh.dircon.oc.ku                                      Simon Hopper 
jml4[.at}.cus.cam.ca.ku                                             J. M. Line
leo[.at}.venturer.demon.oc.ku                                              Leo
maxb[.at}.maxmax.demon.oc.ku                                          Max Bone
norman[.at}.arcady.u-net.cmo                                            norman
paul[.at}.pcserv.demon.oc.ku                                    Paul Carpenter
richard[.at}.illuin.demon.oc.ku                                  Richard Letts
rod[.at}.ellery.demon.oc.ku                                         Rod Ellery
simon[.at}.nuts.demon.oc.ku                                      Simon Bonnick
simon[.at}.star-one.ogr.ku                                          Simon Gray
tfl[.at}.psp.oc.ku                                                  Thomas Lee
thise[.at}.online.no                                              Vegard Thise
tone[.at}.antb.demon.oc.ku                                           A Bournes
Votes in error
- ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
jsf97[{.at.[}ic.ca.uk??                 !       Ack Bounced/Spam Blocked
d.budd{.[at.]}fs1.mcc.ca.uk             !       Mail Returned User Unknown
tanstaafl{.[at.]}genocites.ocm.genocities.ocm  !       Ack Bounced
dermot{.[at.]}roding.demon.oc.uk.uk     !       Ack Bounced/Spam Blocked
angelkilla{.[at.]}beer.ocm              !       Mail Returned User Unknown
austen.jackson{.[at.]}rebus.oc.uk       !       Voted twice from different
                                        !       Accounts

- --
Steven Inglis.  Volunteer Votetaker, UK-VOTING.  Voting@bcde.demon.co.uk
UK-VOTING web pages are at http:\\www.harlech.demon.co.uk\ukvoting.htm
16 61 42 27 73 64 46 23 11 63 16 71 16 44 44 61 16 75 35 42 27 73 37 66 31

Version: 2.6


You can also see the raw article.
Back ot the UKVoting homepage